Rumors Swirl: Are the Giants Losing Faith in Russell Wilson as QB1?
The New York Giants find themselves at the center of a quarterback controversy, and the focus is squarely on Russell Wilson. After an offseason filled with high expectations, questions are now mounting about whether Wilson will remain the team’s starting quarterback heading into the 2025 season.
The Giants acquired Wilson earlier this year, hoping the veteran would bring leadership, experience, and a spark to an inconsistent offense. His arrival came with fanfare, especially after a rocky exit from Denver. Many expected him to turn the page and elevate the Giants’ offense. However, his recent performances in minicamp and OTA sessions have left some fans and analysts raising eyebrows.
According to team insiders, Wilson has struggled with timing and decision-making in practice. While his work ethic remains unquestioned, several missed throws and sluggish reads have opened the door for speculation. Backup quarterbacks Tommy DeVito and rookie Carson Beck have reportedly impressed with their poise and command during drills, turning up the heat on the quarterback room.
Head coach Brian Daboll has remained noncommittal when asked directly about Wilson’s position as QB1. “We’re evaluating everyone,” Daboll told reporters on Thursday. “We want to put the best 11 on the field, regardless of name or past resume.” His statement did little to quiet the noise and only fueled further rumors about a potential shake-up.
Team sources say the coaching staff plans to let the competition play out during training camp. They want to see how Wilson responds under pressure, especially as preseason games approach. While no official change has occurred, the tone around the team suggests that Wilson’s starting role is anything but guaranteed.
Fans, meanwhile, are split. Some believe Wilson deserves a full season to prove himself in the Giants’ system. Others think the team should cut its losses early and develop younger talent. The fan base’s reaction has been vocal on social media, with debates erupting daily over whether Wilson is still the right man for the job.
Financially, the Giants committed heavily to Wilson, taking on a significant portion of his remaining contract. That investment makes a benching a high-stakes move. But in the NFL, performance trumps past achievements, and Wilson will need to earn his spot.
The coming weeks could define the Giants’ quarterback direction for the entire season. If Wilson steps up and silences critics, he could reclaim his reputation as a top-tier leader. But if struggles continue, the Giants may have no choice but to look elsewhere — and fast.
As training camp looms, one thing is clear: the Giants’ quarterback situation is far from settled, and Russell Wilson’s grip on the starting job is slipping.