Mets’ New Bosses Quietly Preparing To Trade Alonso? What The Front Office Isn’t Saying
New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso is a fan favorite, a franchise icon, and the face of the team’s power-hitting identity. But as he nears the end of his two-year, $54 million deal, his future in Queens is far from guaranteed. While the front office, led by President of Baseball Operations David Stearns, has publicly expressed a desire to keep him, insiders reveal a more cautious and potentially calculated approach behind the scenes.
Alonso, who has a player option for the 2026 season, is widely expected to decline it and re-enter free agency. His impressive performance this season, including over 30 home runs and 100 RBIs, has significantly increased his market value, making a long-term, high-dollar contract a certainty. This puts the Mets in a difficult position. With one of the highest payrolls in baseball, the team’s new leadership is wary of adding another massive long-term contract to the books, especially one that could push them deeper into luxury tax territory.
The quiet truth is that the Mets’ front office is not simply preparing to offer Alonso a blank check. Instead, they are evaluating all options, including the possibility of a trade. The team is committed to a sustainable, winning culture, and that may mean tough decisions are ahead. While Alonsoโs trade value is at a peak, a deal would bring in a haul of top prospects and help balance the roster for the future.
While trading a beloved player like Alonso would be a PR nightmare for owner Steve Cohen, the new front office is focused on a long-term plan. The silence from the team regarding any impending long-term deal is not a sign of confidence, but rather a reflection of the team’s private deliberations. The Mets’ future, and Alonso’s place in it, are far from settled, and what isn’t being said is arguably more important than what is.