BREAKING: Following Pete Alonso’s Recent $45 Million Contract With the Mets, Should They Re-Sign Him After the End of the Season?

In a major move earlier this season, the New York Mets signed star first baseman Pete Alonso to a one-year, $45 million deal, avoiding arbitration and signaling their belief in his continued value. However, with that contract set to expire at season’s end, the biggest question now looms: should the Mets re-sign Alonso long-term?

At 30, Alonso remains one of the most feared sluggers in the league. He continues to anchor the Mets’ lineup with elite power, racking up home runs and RBIs at a consistent pace. Off the field, he’s a clubhouse leader and a fan favorite — known for his passion, toughness, and deep ties to the city. Simply put, he’s been the face of the franchise since his record-breaking rookie campaign in 2019.

But there are complications. The Mets, under new President of Baseball Operations David Stearns, are focused on building sustainable success, particularly through younger talent. A massive long-term extension for Alonso — likely exceeding $200 million — could limit flexibility in the years ahead. There’s also the reality that power-hitting first basemen can decline quickly, especially in their 30s.

Still, letting Alonso walk would be risky. He’s not just a homegrown star, he’s the star — and replacing his production would be no small task. Unless the Mets are confident they can fill the void internally or in free agency, a long-term deal may be the safest bet.

As the 2025 offseason approaches, the Mets will have to decide: do they invest in Alonso as a pillar of their future, or take the gamble of moving on from one of the most iconic players in recent team history?

DAVESPORTSCOMPLEX.COM