just in:the conversation surrounding the team’s leadership grows louder

The New York Giants have faced a tumultuous season in 2024, and with every loss, the conversation surrounding the team’s leadership grows louder. While the Giants have made strides in recent seasons, particularly with **Joe Schoen** at the helm as general manager and **Brian Daboll** leading the team as head coach, it has become increasingly clear that the team’s trajectory is heading in the wrong direction. With a disappointing record and a lack of progress, it may be time for the Giants to consider parting ways with both Schoen and Daboll as they look to rebuild the franchise into a perennial contender.

In a league where accountability reigns, the question must be asked: Has the partnership between Schoen and Daboll yielded the results the Giants had hoped for when they were hired in 2022? While Schoen was brought in to lead the front office into a new era, and Daboll was hailed as the offensive mastermind to develop quarterback **Daniel Jones**, the current state of the franchise suggests that both have failed to live up to expectations. The franchise’s recent struggles on both sides of the ball, coupled with roster decisions that have not panned out, suggest that the Giants may need to move on from their current leadership.

### Joe Schoen’s Struggles as General Manager

When Schoen was hired as general manager in 2022, the expectations were high. The Giants were looking for a fresh perspective to steer them away from years of mediocrity and poor decisions under the previous regime. Schoen was expected to rebuild the roster and make the necessary moves to put the team in a position to contend. However, two years into his tenure, the results have been mixed at best, and the franchise has failed to make significant strides forward.

One of the most glaring issues with Schoen’s tenure has been his handling of the quarterback position. While **Daniel Jones** showed flashes of potential early in his career, the front office’s decision to commit to him long-term with a massive extension before the 2024 season raised more than a few eyebrows. Jones has been inconsistent at best, and despite being the centerpiece of Schoen’s plan, he has failed to provide the level of play expected from a top-tier quarterback. Schoen’s decision to extend Jones for four years and $160 million was meant to stabilize the position, but it has instead led to uncertainty. Jones has not elevated his game and has struggled with turnovers and decision-making.

Additionally, Schoen’s moves in free agency and the draft have not produced the desired results. While the general manager made some solid additions, such as **Darren Waller** in a trade with the Las Vegas Raiders, the Giants have failed to build a roster capable of consistently competing. The offensive line, which has been a long-standing weakness for the team, has not been addressed adequately. Despite drafting **Evan Neal** in the first round of the 2022 NFL Draft, the Giants’ line has continued to struggle with protection and consistency. The lack of an elite offensive line, coupled with Jones’ inconsistency, has led to an offense that lacks rhythm and productivity.

Defensively, the team has shown signs of life but has struggled to consistently dominate. While **Dexter Lawrence** and **Kayvon Thibodeaux** are strong pieces, the team’s inability to surround them with sufficient talent in key areas, particularly in the secondary, has left the defense exposed against high-powered offenses.

### Brian Daboll’s Inability to Develop an Identity

When **Brian Daboll** was hired as head coach, he was lauded for his success in turning around the Buffalo Bills’ offense and developing quarterback **Josh Allen** into one of the league’s top passers. The hope was that Daboll could work his magic with Jones and create an offensive scheme that would make the most of his strengths. Unfortunately, Daboll has struggled to do so.

In his first season, Daboll guided the Giants to a surprising playoff berth in 2023, with the offense showing flashes of life under his guidance. However, that success has not been sustained, and the 2024 season has been marked by an offense that looks disjointed, inconsistent, and largely ineffective. The Giants have scored fewer than 20 points in several games this season, and the offensive scheme has failed to adapt to the personnel at Daboll’s disposal.

Daboll’s inability to consistently get the best out of Daniel Jones has been a major point of criticism. Jones has regressed this season, and Daboll has struggled to make adjustments to address the quarterback’s weaknesses. The offense lacks an identity, and the creativity that Daboll was known for in Buffalo has been absent. Instead of developing a high-powered offense, the Giants have been stuck in neutral, unable to move the ball effectively or sustain drives.

The lack of a balanced offense has also hurt the team’s ability to compete. Despite having **Saquon Barkley** — one of the NFL’s most dynamic playmakers — Daboll has not utilized him to his fullest potential. Barkley’s touches have been inconsistent, and the running game has lacked the creativity and explosion that it had in previous seasons. Daboll’s inability to establish a potent ground game has compounded the issues for Jones and the passing attack.

On the defensive side, while **Wink Martindale** has been an asset as the team’s defensive coordinator, Daboll’s inability to generate consistency from the offense has put additional pressure on the defense to carry the team. The defense has often been forced to play from behind, leading to higher-risk situations where they’ve been unable to hold off opposing offenses in critical moments.

### The Need for a New Direction

As the Giants struggle to stay relevant in the competitive NFC East, it’s becoming clear that both Schoen and Daboll have not been able to take the team to the next level. Despite their impressive resumes, their tenure in New York has been marked by inconsistent performance, roster mismanagement, and an inability to develop a sustainable plan for success.

It’s time for the Giants to explore a new direction. Schoen’s lack of success in assembling a competitive roster, combined with Daboll’s struggles to develop a consistent offensive identity, suggests that a change in leadership is necessary for the long-term health of the franchise. Moving on from Schoen and Daboll would allow the Giants to hit the reset button and find leaders who can build a roster capable of competing in the modern NFL while developing a clear identity and strategy for success.

The NFL is a league where time is precious, and teams cannot afford to waste seasons in mediocrity. The Giants need a new front office and coaching staff that can bring in fresh ideas, make sound personnel decisions, and create a long-term vision that puts the franchise in a position to contend for championships.

While it is always difficult to part ways with leaders who have potential, the current trajectory of the Giants under Schoen and Daboll suggests that it may be time for the franchise to move on and begin the next chapter in its rebuilding process. The team’s loyal fan base deserves better than the mediocrity that has plagued the Giants in recent years, and a fresh start could be the key to bringing back the success that has eluded them for far too long.